30 March 2014

The Chinese Technology Paradigm

(THE INTRIGUING TECHNIQUES AND RATIONALITY BEHIND CHINESE PLAGIARISTIC OBSESSION)

The Chinese are double-dyed bootleggers par excellence and they are consummate propagandists evidently traits inspired by their former Soviet masters. Just as in any dictatorship, attention grabbing, diversion or delusive dispersion of information for the domestic audience becomes a cardinal policy for governance and by a reasonable assumption; it goes in with the fodder. Inherently they are hegemonic by nature since the leadership psyche is indoctrinated and fueled by such an ideology which advocates aggressiveness and consequently it is accompanied amply by a will to dominate, having a conniving determination and a firm quest to achieve its goals. To feed these nefarious ends they adopt an artful semblance of posturing seemingly in the intention to rattle their adversaries aspiring to be a step ahead of them either through deceit, larceny or reverse engineering tactics. Bootlegging technology in every sphere of scientific development is a well-honed practice, and it is diligently backed up by massive resource and logistic support. The lists below bears witness to this approximation though some of the equipment is licence produced, but the Chinese have the uncanny habit of deserting or contravening their joint venture agreements and partners and continue manufacturing them under their own branding. Like their former boss-men, the Soviets the Chinese politburo too is compelled to resort to such crack-brained propagandist rhetoric as part of preserving their dictatorship. In at least the cases listed below, desperation by China seems to have won over innovation.

Here is a knock off list of Military Equipment manufactured in China in no particular order:

The Chinese Russian Manned Soyuz Space Capsule: The Shenzhou Manned Spacecraft


The Chinese Russian Sukhoi Su-27SK Flanker: The Shenyang J-11B
The Chinese Russian MiG-17: The Shenyang J-5
The Chinese Russian MiG-19: The Shenyang J-6
The Chinese Russian MiG-19L Ground Attack Aircraft: The Nanchang Qiang-5
The Chinese Russian MiG-21U Mongol-A Trainer: The Jianjiji J-7
The Chinese Russian Sukhoi Su-33: The Shenyang J-15 Flying Shark
The Chinese Russian MIG-21: The Chengdu-F7Shenyang J-8 and later JF-17 Thunder
The Chinese Russian MIG-1.44: The Chengdu J-20 Mighty Dragon
The Chinese Russian MiG-23MS Ground Attack Aircraft: The Nanchang Q-6
The Chinese Russian Antonov An-12: The Shaanxi Y-8
The Chinese Russian Antonov An-24: The Xian MA60
The Chinese Israeli Lavi/Kfir: The Chengdu J-10 (Lavi itself was based on the F-16 Fighting Falcon)
The Chinese Russian Yakolev Yak-130: The Hongdu L-15 Falcon
The Chinese American F-35 Lightening II/F-22 Raptor: The Shenyang J-31 Stealth Fighter

Comparison of Lockheed Martin F-35 and Shenyang J-31

The Chinese American General Atomics MQ-1 Predator Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV): The Chengdu Pterodactyl
The Chinese American General Atomics MQ-9 Reaper UAV: The Wing Loong CH-4 (More Intriguing Information here)
The Chinese American Northrup MQ-8 Fire Scout UAV: The SVU 200 Sunward
The Chinese American Northrop Grumman X-47B Carrier-Based Unmanned Combat Air Vehicle: The Hongdu Lijian (Sharp Sword) 
The Chinese American Northrop Grumman RQ-4 Global Hawk (UAV): The Chengdu Xiang Long (Soaring Dragon)
The Chinese Russian Lavochkin La-17 UAV: The Nanjing Chang Kong (Blue Sky) CK-1
The Chinese Russian RP-5 Izumrud Radar: The SL-1 Radar
The Chinese Russian SRD-5M Radar: The SL-2/ SL-2A Radar
The Chinese Israeli EL/M-2032 Multimode Airborne Fire Control Radar: The Nanjing KLJ-3
The Chinese Russian 64N6E "Big Bird" Anti Missile Phased Array Radar: The Nanjing PAR
The Chinese American Snecma/GE CFM56 High-Bypass Turbofan: The Shenyang WS-10 (Failure)
The Chinese Russian Saturn AL-31F-TVN Turbofan: The Shenyang WS-10A Model
The Chinese Ukrainian Ivchenko AI-25 Turbofan: The Shenyang WS-11
The Chinese Russian Klimov VK-1F Jet Engine: The Shenyang PF-1
The Chinese Russian Tumansky R-9BF-811 Jet Engine: The WP-6
The Chinese Russian Tumansky R-11-300 Jet Engine: The WP-7
The Chinese Russian Mikulin AM-3M-500  Jet Engine: The WP-8
The Chinese Russian Tumansky R-13-300 Jet Engine: The Guizhou WP-13
The Chinese Russian Shvetsov ASh-62 Piston Engine: The Zhuzhou HS-5
The Chinese Russian Ivchenko AI-14R Piston Engine: The Zhuzhou HS-6
The Chinese Russian Shvetsov ASh-82V Piston Engine: The Dongan (Harbin) HS-7
The Chinese Russian Ivchenko AI-24 Turboprop Engine: The Dongan WJ-5
The Chinese American Humvee: The Dongfeng EQ2050 Mengshi ‘Brave Soldier’


The Chinese Russian SA-7 Strela-2 Man Portable Air Defense Systems (MANPAD): The Hong Ying HN-5
The Chinese Russian S-75 Dvina Surface To Air Missile: The Hong Qi  HQ-1 HQ-2 HQ-3, HQ-4 & M-7
The Chinese French Thomson-CSF Crotale Surface To Air Missile: The Hong Qi HQ-7
The Chinese Russian S-300PMU-1 Ballistic Missile Defence System: The Hong Qi HQ-9
The Chinese Russian  S-300PMU-1 Surface To Air Missile: The Hong Qi HQ-15
The Chinese Russian TOR-M1 Short-Range Surface To Air Missile: The Hong Qi HQ-17
The Chinese Russian  S-300P/S-300V Surface To Air Missile: The Hong Qi HQ-9/HQ-18
The Chinese Russian Buk Missile System: The Hong Qi HQ-16
The Chinese Russian 9K22 Tunguska Self Propelled Anti Aircraft Weapon: The CASIC FK-1000
The Chinese Russian Vympel K-13 Air-To-Air Missile : The Easter Machinery Factory PL-2
The Chinese French Matra Magic 550 Air To Air Missile: The Norinco PL-7
The Chinese Israeli Rafael Python-3 Air To Air Missile: The Norinco PL-8/9
The Chinese American AIM-7 Sparrow Beyond Visual Range Missile: The LY-60/FD-60/PL-11/HQ-6/6D
The Chinese American BGM-71 TOW/Franco-German MILAN/MBDA HOT Anti Tank Missile: The HJ-8
The Chinese Israeli Spike Man Portable Anti-Tank System: The Hong Jian-9 (Red Arrow)
The Chinese Russian 9K11 Malyutka Wire Guided Anti Tank Guided Missile: The Hong Jian HJ-73
The Chinese Russian AT-11 9M11/M Svir/Refleks Laser Beam Riding Anti Tank Missile: Exact Copy
The Chinese Russian 9K720 Iskander Tactical Ballistic Missile (TBM): The CPMIEC M20
The Chinese Russian 3M54E Supersonic Sea-Skimming Anti-Ship Missile: The Ying Ji (YJ-18)
The Chinese Russian Kh-31 Sea Skimming Cruise Missile: The Ying Ji 91 (YJ-91)
The Chinese Russian Kh-55 Anti Ship Air Launched Strategic Cruise Missile: The Yingji-83 (C-803)
The Chinese Russian Kh-SD Cruise Missile: The Hong Niao HN-1
The Chinese Ukrainian Kh-55 Cruise Missile: The Dong Hai 10 (DH-10)
The Chinese Russian P-15 Termit Anti Ship Missile: The Shang You SY-series/Hai Ying (HY-series)
The Chinese American Mark 54 MAKO Lightweight Torpedo: The Yu-7 Anti-Submarine Warfare (ASW)
The Chinese Russian T-54A Main Battle Tank: The Type 59 and Type 69/79 Tanks
The Chinese Russian BM-21 GRAD SPMRL Self-Propelled Multiple Rocket Launcher: The Type 81
The Chinese Russian BM-30 SMERCH MRL Multiple Rocket Launcher: The AR-1 MRL
The Chinese Russian Makarov PM (Pistol Marakova): The Norinco Type-59


The Chinese Russian Tokarev TT-30 Self Loading Semi Automatic Pistol: The Norinco Type 51/54
The Chinese American M16 (AR-15) Carbine: The Norinco CQ 5.56 (never adopted)
The Chinese American Colt M4:  The Norinco CQ 5.56mm Type A
The Chinese Czech Republic CZ 75 Semi Automatic Pistol: The Norinco NZ-75
The Chinese Czech Republic CZ 85 Semi Automatic Pistol: The Norinco NZ-85B / NP-40
The Chinese German/Swiss SIG P226 First Pistol: The Norinco NP-22
The Chinese German/Swiss SIG P228 Pistol: The Norinco NP-34
The Chinese German/Swiss SIG P220 Pistol: The Norinco NP-56
The Chinese German/Swiss SIG P226 Pistol-Smith and Wesson Rimless Cartridge: The Norinco NP-58
The Chinese American Colt M1911A1 Para High Cap Pistol: The Norinco NP-28
The Chinese American Colt M1911A1 9mmx19mm Pistol: The Norinco NP-29
The Chinese American Colt M1911A1 Double Column Magazine Pistol: The Norinco NP-30
The Chinese American Colt M1911A1 High Cap Magazine Pistol: The Norinco NP-44
The Chinese American Colt M1911A1 Pistol: The Norinco M-1911A1 Series
The Chinese American M1A M14 Rifle: The Norinco M14S or M305
The Chinese Israeli Uzi-B Open Bolt Blow Back Operated Sub Machine Gun: The Norinco M320
The Chinese German Heckler '&' Koch MP5: The Norinco NR08
The Chinese German Mauser C96 M712 "Schnellfeuer" Automatic Pistol: The Norinco Type 80
The Chinese German Walther PPK: Exact Clone

        Link:   WALTHER PPK           Link:    CHINESE CLONE
The Chinese Russian Kalashnikov PKM General Purpose Machine Gun: The Norinco Type 80
The Chinese Czech .22LR Brno ZKM-451 Center Fire Bolt Action Hunting Rifle: The Norinco JW-15A 
The Chinese Yugoslavian Zastava M48 Bolt Action Rifle: The Norinco JW-101
The Chinese Hungarian FEB P9R Pistol: The Norinco NP-18
The Chinese Russian SKS Semi Automatic Carbine: The Norinco Type 56
The Chinese Russian AK-47 Assault Rifle: The Norinco Type 56
The Chinese Russian Nudelman-Rikhter NR-23 Autocannon: The Norinco Type 23-1 (NR-23)
The Chinese Russian Dragunov SVD-63 Semi Automatic Sniper Marksman Rifle: The Norinco Type 79
The Chinese American Colt Woodsman .22LR Caliber Pistol: The Norinco M93
The Chinese American Winchester Model 1887/1901 Lever Action Shotgun: The Norinco YL-1887L
The Chinese American Winchester Model 1897 Pump Action Shotgun: The Norinco YL-1897
The Chinese American Remington 870 Pump Action Shotgun: The Norinco HP9-1 / 982
The Chinese Russian AKM (Kalashnikov Modernized Automatic) Rifle: The Norinco Type 56


The Chinese Russian RPG-7 Shoulder Launched Anti Tank Rocket Propelled Grenade Launcher: The Norinco Type 69
The Chinese American General Electric M134 Minigun: The Hua Qing CS/LM12
The Chinese Russian Kilo Class Diesel Submarine: The Yuan Class
The Chinese American Sikorsky UH-60 Black Hawk: Harbin Z-20
The Chinese French Eurocopter/Aerospatiale AS350: The Changhe Z-11
The Chinese Russian Mil Mi-4: The Harbin Z-5
The Chinese French Aerospatiale Super Frelon: The Avicopter AC313
The Chinese American Boeing AH-64 Apache: The Changhe WZ-10 Attack Helicopter (Entirely designed by Kamov under a secret contract named Project 941 which looks deceptively like a carbon copy of AH-64)
(A Chinese Changhe WZ-10 attack helicopter crashed in the country's central Shaanxi province on 4th March 2014)


Finally:
The Chinese Ray Ban Sunglasses: The Rat Ban (this is not made up, it is actually true)

Postscript: I have substituted all Soviet origin weapons as Russian for better readability

This scathing report confirms that the Chinese are engaged in high profile cyber espionage published in "The Washington Times" website on 13 March 2014
Read it here:
Top Gun takeover: Stolen F-35 secrets showing up in China’s stealth fighter - Design data on F-35 stolen in 2007

Why are the Chinese so dedicated to copying almost anything from western and other sources? I presume it is cultural by nature. Historically, Chinese folklore propounds that copying is a way of showing respect for human mastery over Science, Technology and the Arts. As an Historical illustration, the Chinese painter and critic Hsieh Ho from the 5th Century AD formulated the "Six Principles of Painting", which included a tenet "to convey and change by patterned representation", which translates subtly "to transmit by copying". Nevertheless, this does not justify the ruse of blatant infringements of intellectual property rights or innovating on other people’s creativity. However, it would be foolhardy to infer that the Chinese are all but champion bootleggers of modern technology; then again it would also be prudent on the part of India to believe and accept the fact that they do have some levels of technological capabilities to develop sophisticated military hardware.

Most of their ostentatious grandstanding, posturing and fully loaded blustering is done periodically for both their domestic and international audiences and to augment the rhetoric, they resort to tacit intimidation of its neighbors. Regardless of this sheer vain conceited posture and even in the event of collusion with Pakistan, India will be able to retaliate in an effective manner. A point to introspect here is that our defense policy always focused in developing mainly defensive weapon systems rather than offensive ones. The Prithvi Defence Vehicle (PDV) or Advanced Air Defense (AAD) anti ballistic missile batteries will take care of the DF-15's and DF-21's or the Pakistani Shaheen-1 and 2 (Imported Chinese M-11 and M-18 missiles), the H-6K (Tupolev Tu-16's) are conventional vintage strategic bombers without any stealth abilities, our Akash SAM's will take care of them as well. In retaliation our offensive response will be with Agni-V ICBM's and Brahmos 1 and 2 supersonic/hyper-sonic missiles. INS Vikrant, INS Viraat and INS Vikramaditya can do carrier service in the east and the west coast.

To put things in perspective, India unlike China has taken a more conservative and holier-than-thou approach in its weapons development programs, take the case of the Tejas as an example it has taken more than two decades for the warplane to evolve as a credible fighting system and it is still limping toward its crucial Final Operational Clearance (FOC). The long gestation period between conception (1990) and the final commissioning of the fighter was on account of new technologies being adopted for the first time in India. Several cutting edge technologies were realized during this period.

Some of the key technologies developed ingeniously for the Tejas are:

  • Tejas employs Relaxed Static Stability design in its architecture. In aviation, relaxed stability is the tendency of an aircraft to change its attitude and angle of bank on its own accord. An aircraft with relaxed stability will oscillate in simple harmonic motion around a particular attitude at increasing amplitude
  • It is equipped with a sophisticated quadruplex digital fly-by-wire (FBW) flight control system
  • Tejas employs a powerful digital flight control computer (DFCC) comprising of four computing channels, each with its own independent power supply and all housed in a single LRU (Line Replaceable Units)
  • Tejas is constructed using aluminium-lithium alloys, carbon-fiber composites (C-FC) and titanium-alloy steels
  • The computer interfaces with pilot display systems like the MFDs (Multi Function Display) is through the MIL-STD-1553B multiplex avionics data buses and RS-422 serial links. MIL-STD-1553 is a military standard published by the United States Department of Defense that defines the mechanical, electrical, and functional characteristics of a serial data bus
  • Tejas is also to be equipped with an Infra-Red Search and Track (IRST) sensor
  • The Electronic Warfare (EW) suite, known as Mayavi (Magician), includes a Radar Warning Receiver (RWR), Missile Approach Warning (MAW) and a Laser Warning Receiver (LWR) system, self-protection jammer, laser warning system and chaff/flare dispenser
  • Tejas is equipped with LRDE's 3D Multi-mode radar which uses contemporary ADSP processors, this radar has been superseded by the new 3D Active Electronically Scanned Array (AESA) Fire Control Radar (FCR) and a Synthetic Aperture and Inverse Synthetic Aperture radar
The obvious benefits one derives from such an approach of developing critical high technologies under our own steam will enable the forces to have equipment availability in case of any exigencies. This will not only benefit a particular program but will also have a snowballing effect on future programs and have considerable commercial spin-offs as well. The development of Tejas is just but one of the few developments that India has undertaken, there are several other milestones achieved in developing critical technologies such as Avionics, UAV, Remotely Controlled Robots, Turbofan Jet Engines, Small Arms, Artillery Systems, EW Systems, Radars, Torpedoes, Mines and Targets, Tanks and Armored vehicles, Spy Satellites, CL-20 Explosives, Command and Control software and decision-making tools, Computing Technologies, Chemical Kit for detection of explosives, lethal and non-lethal directed Laser Energy Weapons (DEWs), Sonar systems, complex Anti-Ballistic Missiles Theater Defensive Systems and Ballistic Missile Systems. The list is very exhaustive. Our only hope is that all these endeavors would finally see the light of day very soon.